Tyler Shough Signs Fully Guaranteed Rookie Contract

Tyler Shough of Louisville emerged as one of the most talked-about quarterback prospects leading up to this year’s draft. While some questioned both his age and skill set, others saw in him the ideal physical frame with significant upside potential for an NFL career. The New Orleans Saints decided to roll the dice on him, and Shough has now officially inked his four-year rookie contract. The deal, a fully guaranteed agreement many expected, is valued at a considerable $10.8 million over four years.

Yet, Shough’s contract carries perks that extend beyond the headline numbers. At 6-foot-5 and 220 pounds, he boasts the classic NFL quarterback build that naturally catches the eye. However, it’s not merely his stature that excites scouts and coaches; offensive coordinators are particularly impressed by his refined abilities. Shough showcases a quick release, can deliver passes from multiple arm angles, and blends both finesse and power to place accurate throws all across the field. His precision on the move enhances his versatility, making him a dynamic weapon for any offensive scheme.

Nonetheless, Shough’s path to the professional ranks is not without significant caveats. His limited starting experience stands out—he has only completed a single full season as a starter across seven years of college play. Moreover, his entry into the NFL at age 26 sets him apart from the typical rookie, prompting doubts about how long his developmental arc might last. Shough is also prone to launching what some characterize as “throwing up prayers,” a style that can produce spectacular plays but also increases the risk of turnovers. This blend of high risk and high reward gives him tantalizing upside yet introduces notable vulnerabilities.

The circumstances surrounding Shough’s arrival with the Saints add further layers of interest. After Derek Carr’s sudden retirement in the middle of the offseason, Shough’s role on the squad became more defined. He arrives at training camp competing for the 2025 starting quarterback spot, contending against Spencer Rattler and Jake Haener—both of whom benefit from previous NFL experience. Shough’s college history suggests he performs well in competitive quarterback battles, having secured starting roles over tough opponents. However, he now faces a greater hurdle, attempting to surpass players already acclimated to professional play. This dynamic is particularly important given Shough's status as the oldest rookie quarterback since Brandon Weeden, who entered the league at 28. At 26, Shough’s age aligns more closely with Weeden’s timeline rather than younger rookies like Bo Nix and Michael Penix Jr., who each joined the NFL at 24 last year.

Beyond the contract’s monetary and competition-related aspects, Shough’s deal with New Orleans features an innovative roster bonus structure—not typically seen in non-first-round selections—that guarantees the bulk of his earnings are paid out annually during the initial week of training camp. This unique financial arrangement underscores the Saints’ belief in his potential while providing him with early-season financial security.

With Shough now signed, the Saints have locked in agreements with all nine of their 2025 draft picks, marking the end of their rookie contract negotiations and signaling the completion of their roster-building efforts heading into the upcoming season.